Assessment tool

Ethical Reasoning Rubric

Read, print, or adapt this ethical reasoning rubric.

All educatorsRead online + download

Stakeholders and impact

4
Identifies affected groups, unequal impact, and duties
3
Identifies major stakeholders
2
Omits important perspectives
1
Focuses on self or one party only
Notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.

Facts and uncertainty

4
Separates evidence, inference, and missing information
3
Notes most uncertainty
2
Mixes fact and assumption
1
Makes unsupported claims
Notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.

Authority and obligations

4
Integrates permission, policy, law, ethics, and professional duty
3
Uses relevant rules
2
Names rules without application
1
Ignores boundaries
Notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.

Alternatives and safeguards

4
Compares feasible options and mitigations
3
Offers more than one option
2
Alternatives are weak
1
Presents no real alternative
Notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.

Justification

4
Clear decision, reasoning, limitations, and review conditions
3
Defensible reasoning
2
Partial or inconsistent reasoning
1
Opinion without support
Notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.

Source and use

The Complete Cybersecurity Educator · Dr. Jason Edwards. Editable companion - Ethical Reasoning Rubric.

Please do not resell this resource. You may repost or share it with other educators; keep the Bare Metal Cyber Educators Hub URL and source attribution intact. See the companion permissions. Use fictional or appropriately authorized material and follow the safety guidance in each resource.

Help improve the Educators Hub.Report a mistake, request a resource, or suggest an improvement.
Send feedback →