- Course / assessment
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
- Rubric version
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
- Calibration lead
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
- Session date
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
- Participating graders
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
- Next calibration
- ________________________________Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Use calibration when multiple people grade the same assessment, when a rubric changes, or when scoring drift is likely. The goal is a shared interpretation of observable evidence and the rubric.
Calibration Workflow
- Prepare 3-5 anonymized samples representing clear, borderline, and difficult cases.
- Have each grader score the same samples independently before discussion.
- Compare criterion-level scores, not only total scores, and identify material variance.
- Discuss the evidence that led to each rating and clarify observable rubric language.
- Record agreed interpretations, edge cases, and any required rubric changes.
- Rescore one or more samples; if important disagreement remains, escalate before grading the full set.
Calibration Record
| Sample | Criterion | Grader A | Grader B | Grader C | Difference / issue | Agreed interpretation |
|---|
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
Decision Log
| Rubric criterion / issue | Decision or clarification | Applies from | Owner | Needs rubric update? |
|---|
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
Operational Guardrails
- Use anonymized or institutionally authorized student work for calibration.
- Do not change a learner’s standard after grading has begun without applying the change consistently under institutional policy.
- Calibration is about evidence and criteria, not forcing a grade distribution.
- Document material rubric interpretations so future faculty can apply the same standard.
- Schedule a midpoint calibration when the assessment is high stakes or the grading window is long.
Source and use
Bare Metal Cyber Educators Hub · Dr. Jason Edwards. Assessment & Academic Quality Toolkit - Grading Calibration Guide.
Please do not resell this resource. You may repost or share it with other educators; keep the Bare Metal Cyber Educators Hub URL and source attribution intact. Use fictional or appropriately authorized material and follow the safety guidance in each resource.